Kitchen & Cooking 6 models
Whirlpool Ice Maker Replacement Guide: OEM and Aftermarket Modules Compared
As Amazon Associates, we earn from qualifying purchases. This means we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you if you click through and make a purchase.
When selecting a whirlpool icemaker replacement, the primary failure point is rarely the ice mold itself, but rather a mismatch between the replacement module, harness connectors, and the shutoff mechanism. Determining the correct replacement requires diagnosing whether your appliance uses a mechanical bail arm shutoff or an electronic infrared optical beam across the bin. Installing an incompatible module leads directly to flooded freezer floors, persistent cycling failure, or an ice bin that fails to register when full.
This guide analyzes exactly 6 models to clarify the critical differences across modern modular ice assemblies. While some options provide complete factory assemblies backed by manufacturer guarantees, others offer bare replacement bodies designed for salvaging your original wiring harness and shutoff components. Navigating the choice between an OEM vs aftermarket whirlpool ice maker comes down to matching your existing connector pins, understanding thermal fuse protection, and confirming compatibility with your specific freezer configuration.
Which Whirlpool Ice Maker Replacements Should You Buy
- For standard top-mount or legacy side-by-side freezer configurations requiring a full drop-in unit: 4317943 Icemaker Kit for Whirlpool Refrigerator
- For side-by-side models featuring in-door ice storage that rely on optical beam boards: New Refrigerator Icemaker Ice Maker
- For repairers seeking to salvage an intact wiring harness and mounting bracket: Bare Ice Maker Fits Whirlpool WPW10190965
- For refrigerators needing replacement mechanical components while retaining existing wiring: W10300022 WPW10300022 Refrigerator Ice Maker Replaces
- For modern French door and side-by-side refrigerators demanding factory engineering standards and warranty coverage: Whirlpool W10873791 Genuine OEM SxS Refrigerator
- For high-demand optical bin units requiring efficient 8-cube batch cycles: 2198597 Ice Maker
4317943 Icemaker Kit for Whirlpool Refrigerator
4317943 Icemaker Kit for Whirlpool Refrigerator
8.4/10 Our score
- Dimensions
- 11.4 x 4.6 x 4.8 inches
Best for: Standard top-mount freezer repairs
Pros
- High 185W ejector heater
- Broad legacy part interchange
- Pre-assembled housing kit
Cons
- Listing lacks harness length spec
The 4317943 Icemaker Kit for Whirlpool Refrigerator provides a self-contained module engineered to replace older mechanical production assemblies across standard residential refrigerators. Operating at 115 volts and drawing 185 watts of power, this assembly integrates a high-output heating element designed to quickly release crescent cubes from the mold before the sweep arm completes its harvest rotation. This whirlpool 4317943 icemaker kit is pre-configured to replace common historical parts such as RIM943, 4210317, 797991, 625601, W10122496, 833701, W10281545, and W10190952, making it an expansive service option for legacy home appliances.
This replacement suits homeowners tackling a failed harvest cycle on top-mount freezer platforms where the ice mold heater has burned out or the internal drive gear has stripped. The assembly measures 11.4 inches deep by 4.6 inches wide by 4.8 inches high with a 1-liter batch capacity, matching the standard footprint of conventional side-wall freezer mounts. If your appliance is a modern French door model with an internal door dispenser, this mechanical kit gives way to newer compact assemblies designed specifically for isolated door cavities.
- Directly replaces legacy part numbers including RIM943, 4210317, 797991, 625601, W10122496, 833701, and W10281545
- 185-watt ejector heater ensures rapid mold detachment during the ejection cycle
- Compatible with refrigerator models including AH530-720/01, AH530-790/01, CK171614/01, and the A8RX series
- Standard 115-volt single-pack assembly designed for top and side freezer wall mounting
New Refrigerator Icemaker Ice Maker
New Refrigerator Icemaker Ice Maker
8.4/10 Our score
- Color
- White
- Dimensions
- 12 x 5.5 x 7 inches
- Weight
- 2.75 Pounds
Best for: In-door optics freezer bins
Pros
- Dedicated deflector stripper arm
- Fused 10.5-inch harness
- Optic sensor board ready
Cons
- Non-OEM aftermarket manufacture
The New Refrigerator Icemaker Ice Maker is specifically engineered for freezer units where the ice bin is mounted inside the door rather than resting directly beneath the harvest mold. Operating in tandem with an electronic emitter board, this aftermarket unit dispenses with traditional shutoff bail arms entirely. It relies on the refrigerator’s internal infrared sensor beam to detect accumulated ice height. Designed as a functional alternative for the whirlpool 2198597 ice maker assembly, it features a specialized deflector stripper arm that directs falling ice away from the wall cavity straight down into the door-mounted storage chute.
This unit provides the right fit for owners maintaining a whirlpool side by side refrigerator fitted with an optical receiver and transmitter control board. The included electrical wiring harness measures 10.5 inches in length with a flat rectangular 4-pin plug, outfitted with integrated fuse protection to prevent line surges from reaching the modular motor head. This model gives way to standard mechanical kits if your freezer shutoff relies on a metallic wire bail arm that physically lifts when cubes accumulate.
- Direct replacement for part numbers 2198597, 2198598, 626663, AP3182733, PS869316, W10190960, and W10122502
- Integrated 10.5-inch flat rectangular 4-pin harness equipped with in-line thermal fuse protection
- Engineered specifically for optical board emitter sensing systems in door-storage configurations
- Specialized ice stripper plate geometry deflects crescent ice cleanly into door-mounted buckets
Bare Ice Maker Fits Whirlpool WPW10190965
Bare Ice Maker Fits Whirlpool WPW10190965
9.6/10 Our scoreTop scored: 9.4/10 or higher
- Color
- WPW10190965
- Size
- 4317943
Best for: Salvaging existing harnesses and arms
Pros
- Durable metal and plastic body
- Direct mold cavity replacement
- Extensive cross-compatibility
Cons
- Lacks wiring and bail arm
The Bare Ice Maker Fits Whirlpool WPW10190965 is a stripped-down core assembly intended for repairers who want to restore mechanical freezing and ejection functions while reusing their existing wiring harness, shutoff arm, and exterior mounting brackets. Built with a metal mold and durable plastic housing components, this module receives water directly through the refrigerator’s inlet valve, freezes the reservoir solid, and triggers an automatic sweep across the fingers to deliver ice to the bin. It is configured as a WPW10190965 ice maker replacement and fits legacy base numbers such as D7824706Q, 10549201, 61005508, 67001263, and 8170937.
This bare unit is tailored for technicians and practical DIY homeowners who have tested their existing wiring harness and bail arm switch and found them fully operational. Because the listing does not include peripheral wiring adapters or mounting plates, purchasing this unit prevents unnecessary expenditure on redundant brackets. However, if your original harness plug shows thermal scorching, melted pins, or physical damage, this bare chassis must give way to a fully equipped kit that provides brand-new wiring leads.
- Constructed from heavy-duty metal mold cavity and resilient plastic motor drive housing
- Serves as a bare replacement core for D7824706Q, WPW10190965, 4317943, and 1129313
- Operates on standard 115-volt domestic residential line power
- Direct mechanical interchange across Whirlpool, Roper, Estate, and related brand lines
W10300022 WPW10300022 Refrigerator Ice Maker Replaces
W10300022 WPW10300022 Refrigerator Ice Maker Replaces
9.2/10 Our score
- Product Group
- Major Appliances
- Binding
- Tools & Home Improvement
Best for: Replacing worn modular gear heads
Pros
- Includes new bail arm
- Includes fresh water trough
- Stainless steel components
Cons
- Requires reusing existing harness
The W10300022 WPW10300022 Refrigerator Ice Maker Replaces addresses common mechanical wear issues by providing the mechanical working elements along with the primary service wear components. Manufactured with stainless steel and durable polymer hardware, this WPW10300022 modular ice maker kit includes a fresh front head cover, a pre-formed shutoff bail arm, a water fill trough, and clear installation instructions. It functions as a direct interchange for part numbers AP6019085, W10122556, W10300022, W10377190, and legacy D7824706Q configurations across extensive Maytag and Amana production lines.
This assembly suits users whose existing icemaker suffers from a cracked water fill cup, calcium-fouled guide troughs, or a bent shutoff arm that prevents proper cycling. The listing explicitly states that an electrical wiring cord is not included with this unit; installers must detach the plug-in wiring harness from their old module and reconnect it to this head. When resolving sudden electrical heating or production failures like you would when diagnosing a whirlpool oven heating element, verifying harness continuity is critical before transferring the original cord onto this fresh module.
- Package includes modular head cover, metal bail arm, water fill trough, and setup documentation
- Replaces multiple part numbers including AP6019085, W10122556, W10300022, and W10377190
- Engineered to fit specific series including Maytag MZD, MSD, and Amana PARB and AFD platforms
- Utilizes stainless steel components for heightened moisture resistance and structural durability
Whirlpool W10873791 Genuine OEM SxS Refrigerator
Whirlpool W10873791 Genuine OEM SxS Refrigerator
8.4/10 Our score
- Dimensions
- 7.44 x 14.44 x 7.38 inches
Best for: Modern side-by-side factory restoration
Pros
- Factory OEM build quality
- Official one-year warranty
- Complete 10-cube assembly
Cons
- Limited legacy model compatibility
The Whirlpool W10873791 Genuine OEM SxS Refrigerator represents the original factory-standard engineering benchmark for late-model side-by-side appliances. As an official genuine part, this whirlpool W10873791 replacement assembly produces 10-cube crescent batches and comes completely integrated with its dedicated structural housing, internal motor drive, and factory connection points. It supersedes older engineering revisions including W10760070, W10798411, W10847507, W11130444, and W11646278, maintaining factory tolerances without requiring bracket bending or wiring retrofits.
This OEM assembly suits consumers who prioritize long-term component reliability and support over generic compatibility. Backed by an official one-year warranty directly from the manufacturer, it eliminates the guesswork associated with aftermarket fitment on high-end refrigerators like model numbers WRS571CIHZ, WRS588FIHZ, WRS555SIHZ, KRSC703HPS, and WRS588FIHV. Weighing 1.43 pounds with dimensions of 7.44 by 14.44 by 7.38 inches, it gives way to mechanical aftermarket models only when servicing legacy refrigerators built around older 8-cube side-wall assemblies.
- Genuine OEM factory replacement backed by a complete one-year manufacturer warranty
- Direct superseding unit for part numbers W10760070, W10798411, W10847507, W11130444, and W11646278
- Engineered specifically for premium models such as WRS571CIHZ, WRS588FIHZ, and KRSC703HPS
- Complete 10-cube production assembly including pre-aligned housing and wire connections
2198597 Ice Maker
Best for: Sensor-based in-door ice systems
Pros
- Food-grade safe contact plastics
- High-efficiency 8-cube mold
- Modern R600a system certified
Cons
- No shutoff arm included
The 2198597 Ice Maker delivers an efficient 8-cube harvest cycle specifically tailored for optical emitter side-by-side refrigerators. Built around an internal 185-watt ejector mechanism operating on standard 115-volt 60Hz household power, this module uses food-grade materials to safeguard ice taste and cleanliness. Designed to resolve persistent ice room failures such as stripped gear movement, internal mold leaks, and noisy ejection cycles, it replaces common part references including W10122502, 626663, 1016069, and 2198678.
This aftermarket assembly is built for consumers maintaining appliances across the JCB and JCD series, including models like JCB2488MTR00 and JCD2395WES00. It is critical to note that this specific product does not include a lifting shutoff arm. It must operate in cabinets featuring built-in infrared optical sensors to detect ice capacity. If your freezer relies on a physical metal arm to interrupt the harvest rotation, this unit will fail to shut down and will inevitably overfill your storage bin.
- Produces standard 8-cube harvests using a high-efficiency 185-watt ejector heater
- Compatible with extensive model runs including JCB2488MTR00, JCB2581WES00, and JCD2395WES00
- Manufactured strictly with certified food-grade contact materials
- Engineered for direct communication with cabinet optic sensors without requiring a mechanical arm
What Sets These Models Apart
Choosing the correct replacement ice assembly requires evaluating more than just external dimensions. The primary functional divide exists between modules that rely on integrated mechanical shutoff arms versus those designed for optical infrared beam sensing across the storage bucket. Additionally, determining whether an assembly includes an internal wiring harness or requires salvaging your existing electrical connector determines installation complexity and overall repair reliability.
| Model Name | Shutoff Sensing Type | Included Wiring Cord | Batch Configuration |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4317943 Icemaker Kit for Whirlpool Refrigerator | Mechanical Bail Arm | Not specified in listing | Standard crescent mold |
| New Refrigerator Icemaker Ice Maker | Optical Emitter Sensor | Included (10.5-inch 4-pin fused) | In-door deflection mold |
| Bare Ice Maker Fits Whirlpool WPW10190965 | Chassis only (reusable arm) | Not included (bare core) | Standard bare mold |
| W10300022 WPW10300022 Refrigerator Ice Maker Replaces | Mechanical Bail Arm included | Not included (reuse original) | Modular replacement mold |
| Whirlpool W10873791 Genuine OEM SxS Refrigerator | Internal Integrated Sensor | Included complete assembly | 10-cube OEM assembly |
| 2198597 Ice Maker | Optical Sensor (no arm) | Not specified in listing | 8-cube high efficiency |
Buying Tips for Whirlpool Ice Maker Replacements
Before purchasing any whirlpool refrigerator ice maker assembly, remove the existing module and inspect the electrical harness plug on the freezer cabinet wall. Some freezer models feature a round 4-pin plug, while others accept a flat rectangular inline connector. Installing an aftermarket ice maker with an incompatible harness end requires splicing wires inside a freezing environment, which introduces resistance points and increases the risk of thermal fuse failure. Verifying harness length and pin shape beforehand ensures a secure, plug-and-play installation.
Understanding the difference between OEM and third-party modules protects your appliance investment. While an aftermarket replacement module offers functional mechanics for older platforms, a genuine OEM unit comes backed by a dedicated manufacturer warranty and adheres to strict electrical safety standards. Routine maintenance of your entire water loop—including regular changes of your water filter or secondary systems like a profile ice maker filter—prevents sediment accumulation in the inlet valve, extending the functional life of any replacement ice mold you install.
FAQ
How do I know which whirlpool ice maker to buy for my refrigerator?
Locate the model sticker on the inside cabinet wall of your refrigerator, not the serial tag on the exterior door. Cross-reference that complete model number against part catalogs to see whether your platform calls for a mechanical arm model, a bare replacement core, or an optics-driven in-door ice assembly.
What is the primary difference in an OEM vs aftermarket whirlpool ice maker?
A genuine OEM assembly is manufactured directly to factory specifications and carries official one-year warranty backing. Aftermarket replacements provide compatible form and mechanical function, but they frequently omit wiring harnesses, reuse existing bail arms, or lack extended manufacturer coverage.
Why does my new ice maker fail to turn off when the bin fills?
This failure occurs when an optical-style ice maker that lacks a mechanical shutoff arm is accidentally installed in a freezer designed for mechanical bail arms, or when the infrared emitter beam on an in-door system is misaligned or obstructed.
Can I reuse the wiring harness from my old ice maker?
Yes, provided the original wires show no signs of brittle insulation, corrosion, or heat damage at the plastic terminal connectors. Several aftermarket kits, such as bare units and modular assemblies, are specifically designed for the installer to transfer the original harness.
Why is ice production slow after installing a new replacement kit?
A replacement ice maker will not begin its initial cycle until the internal mold thermostat reaches approximately 15 degrees Fahrenheit. Allow the freezer compartment at least 12 to 24 hours to reach stable operating temperature before diagnosing production issues.
Prices and specifications on this page are read from the Amazon product listing and can change at any time. Scores are out of 10, based on listed specifications and buyer feedback. Nobody at this site handled or measured these products.
