Skip to content
BuyDeck.net

Fire Pits

Solo Stove Basecamp 24-Inch Smokeless Fire vs Solo Stove 42″ Fire Pit Surround (2026): Key Differences

By BuyDeck Editorial Team 4 Nov 2026 6 min read

As Amazon Associates, we earn from qualifying purchases. This means we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you if you click through and make a purchase.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.

The solo stove basecamp 24 inch smokeless fire vs 42 fire pit surround comparison highlights two distinct Solo Stove products. Both items share the brand name and outdoor focus, yet they serve different roles. The Basecamp is a complete, smokeless wood-burning fire pit designed for heat and cooking. The 42 Surround is a protective barrier and tabletop accessory. You need to decide between a primary heat source or a safety and utility add-on for an existing setup.

Primary Function

Smokeless wood-burning fire pit

Protective barrier and tabletop

Fuel Type

Wood-Fired

Not listed

Color

Silver

Black

Material

Stainless steel

Powder-coated steel and UV-resistant fabric

Weight

30.5 lbs

46 pounds

Choose the first if

  • You need a complete, smokeless wood-burning fire pit for heat and cooking.
  • You prefer a stainless steel construction that develops a unique patina over time.
  • You want a portable unit that includes a stand to protect sensitive surfaces.

Choose the second if

  • You already own a fire pit and need a protective barrier to keep children and pets safe.
  • You want a tabletop surface for snacks and drinks around your existing fire.
  • You prefer a black, powder-coated steel accessory with adjustable feet for various ground types.

Verdict

Choose the Basecamp if you need a standalone fire pit that provides heat, cooking capability, and smokeless efficiency. Choose the 42 Surround if you already have a compatible fire pit and want to add safety, stability, and a convenient tabletop surface. These products complement each other rather than compete directly.

Basecamp 24 vs 42 Surround Specs

Primary Function

Edge: Tie

The Solo Stove Basecamp 24-Inch Smokeless Fire Pit is a complete, standalone unit designed for wood burning. It features a patented 360° airflow design that re-burns smoke for cleaner combustion. You get a self-contained fire experience with a removable ash pan for easy cleanup. In contrast, the Solo Stove 42" Fire Pit Surround is an accessory, not a fire pit itself. It acts as a protective barrier and tabletop for other fire pits. It does not generate heat or burn fuel on its own. It is meant to enhance an existing fire setup with safety and surface space.

Build Material

Edge: Tie

The Basecamp 24-Inch is constructed from premium stainless steel. This material offers corrosion resistance and long-lasting durability in outdoor conditions. Over time, the steel naturally develops a unique golden blue patina, which adds character without compromising structural integrity. The 42" Fire Pit Surround uses a different approach. It is made from powder-coated steel combined with UV-resistant outdoor fabric. This combination provides weatherproof durability and resists wear and tear. The powder coating helps protect the steel, while the fabric adds a distinct aesthetic and texture to the tabletop surface.

Weight and Portability

Edge: Solo Stove Basecamp 24-Inch Smokeless Fire Pit

Portability differs significantly between these two items. The Basecamp 24-Inch Fire Pit weighs 30.5 lbs. This lightweight design allows you to easily reposition the unit for various outdoor settings, from backyard patios to camping trips. It includes a protective stand that elevates the pit, protecting sensitive surfaces from heat. The 42" Fire Pit Surround is heavier, weighing 46 pounds. While still portable, the increased weight suggests it is less likely to be moved frequently. It is designed to stay in place, providing a stable platform for drinks and snacks around a fire.

Dimensions and Size

Edge: Solo Stove 42" Fire Pit Surround

Size specifications highlight their distinct purposes. The Basecamp 24-Inch has a diameter of 24.6 inches and a height of 17.8 inches. This spacious design comfortably accommodates small groups of five to seven people, creating a central gathering point. The 42" Fire Pit Surround has varying dimensions depending on the size option. The Small version measures 31 inches in length, 6 inches in width, and 23 inches in height. The Large version extends to 52.6 inches in length. These dimensions indicate a larger footprint designed to encircle a fire pit rather than serve as the fire source itself.

Safety and Protection

Edge: Solo Stove 42" Fire Pit Surround

Safety features are a key differentiator. The Basecamp 24-Inch relies on its elevated design and included stand to protect decks and patios from heat damage. It does not include a physical barrier to prevent contact with the hot stainless steel exterior. The 42" Fire Pit Surround is explicitly designed for enhanced safety. It features a 360° protective barrier that keeps wandering hands and pets away from the fire. This barrier also serves as a tabletop, allowing you to place snacks and drinks safely within reach. It provides a secure perimeter that the Basecamp lacks on its own.

Choose Your Solo Stove Setup

You want a complete smokeless fire pit

Our pick: Solo Stove Basecamp 24-Inch Smokeless Fire Pit

The Basecamp 24 is a standalone unit with a 24.6-inch diameter and 17.8-inch height. Its 360-degree airflow design reduces smoke for cleaner burns. At 30.5 lbs, it is portable and includes a stand to protect surfaces. This all-in-one solution handles wood burning efficiently without needing extra accessories.

You need a protective tabletop barrier

Our pick: Solo Stove 42" Fire Pit Surround

The 42 Fire Pit Surround acts as a safety barrier and tabletop. It measures 31 inches in length and 23 inches in height. Constructed from powder-coated steel, it resists UV damage. The adjustable feet allow stable placement on grass, gravel, or concrete. It keeps hands and pets safe while providing a surface for drinks.

You prioritize surface protection and stability

Our pick: Solo Stove 42" Fire Pit Surround

This surround features adjustable feet designed for sensitive surfaces like wooden decks. Its 46-pound weight provides stability. The perforated design promotes airflow while minimizing heat absorption. It creates a protected zone around your fire, ensuring safety for children and pets while elevating your outdoor setup with a functional tabletop surface.

1
Solo Stove Basecamp 24-Inch Smokeless Fire Pit

Solo Stove Basecamp 24-Inch Smokeless Fire Pit

Best for: Small outdoor gatherings seeking smokeless efficiency

Fuel Type
Wood
Outer Size
24.6 inches
Primary Material
Stainless steel
Color
Silver
Design
Smokeless
Dimensions
24.6 × 24.6 × 17.8 inches

The Solo Stove Basecamp 24-inch fire pit uses a 360° airflow design to burn wood cleanly. Measuring 24.6 inches wide and 17.8 inches high, it fits groups of five to seven people. The stainless steel build resists corrosion and develops a patina. It weighs 30.5 lbs and includes a stand to protect surfaces. This unit offers efficient burning and easy cleanup via a removable ash pan.

Pros
  • 360° airflow design reduces smoke and improves burn efficiency
  • 24.6-inch diameter comfortably seats five to seven people
  • Corrosion-resistant stainless steel construction with included protective stand
  • Lightweight 30.5 lb build for easy repositioning
Cons
  • 24.6-inch diameter is smaller than the 42-inch surround option
  • 17.8-inch height limits fire visibility compared to taller models
  • 30.5 lb weight adds bulk for frequent transport
Good fit if
  • You need a smokeless fire pit for small group gatherings
  • You want a stainless steel unit that resists corrosion
  • You require a protective stand to shield decks or patios
Skip if
  • You need a fire pit for large parties exceeding seven people
  • You prefer a wider diameter for more seating space
  • You want a taller fire pit for better visibility

Verdict: Solo Stove Basecamp 24" Smokeless Fire Pit fits backyard gatherings of five to seven people who want a compact, smokeless wood-burning option. Its smaller 24.6-inch diameter suits those prioritizing portability over maximum seating capacity.

2
Solo Stove 42" Fire Pit Surround

Solo Stove 42" Fire Pit Surround

Best for: Safety and a stable tabletop for bonfires

Outer Size
42"
Primary Material
Powder-coated steel
Smoker Style
Portable
Color
Black
Dimensions
31 × 6 × 23 inches
Weight
46 pounds

The Solo Stove 42" Fire Pit Surround is a protective barrier and tabletop for your fire pit. It measures 31 inches long, 23 inches high, and weighs 46 pounds. The powder-coated steel construction is UV resistant. Adjustable feet allow it to sit on grass, gravel, concrete, or wooden decks. This setup keeps wandering hands or pets safe while providing a stable surface for drinks and snacks.

Pros
  • 360-degree protective barrier for safety
  • Powder-coated steel and UV-resistant fabric
  • Adjustable feet for stability on various surfaces
  • Perforated surface minimizes heat absorption
Cons
  • Weighs 46 pounds, making it less portable
  • Limited to Small (20×42) and Large (20.5×52.6) sizes
Good fit if
  • You want a protective barrier around your fire pit
  • You need a stable tabletop for outdoor gatherings
  • You have a wooden deck, grass, or concrete surface
Skip if
  • You need a smokeless fire pit without an accessory
  • You prefer a lightweight and highly portable setup
  • You require a larger tabletop than the Large size offers

Verdict: Solo Stove 42" Fire Pit Surround provides a sturdy, safe, and stylish addition to your outdoor fire pit. It is ideal for those who prioritize safety and a dedicated surface for their bonfire setup.

Specifications side by side

SpecSolo Stove Basecamp 24-Inch Smokeless Fire PitSolo Stove 42" Fire Pit Surround
Fuel TypeWood–
Outer Size24.6 inches42"
Primary MaterialStainless steelPowder-coated steel
FuelWood-Fired–
Smoker Style–Portable
ColorSilverBlack
DesignSmokeless–
Dimensions24.6 × 24.6 × 17.8 inches31 × 6 × 23 inches
Weight–46 pounds
ModelSS24-SD-2.0Firepit Surround
Size–Small (20×42)

Frequently asked questions

Can I use the Solo Stove 42" Fire Pit Surround with my existing fire pit?

Yes, the Solo Stove 42" Fire Pit Surround is designed to be an accessory for your outdoor fire setup. It provides a sturdy and safe boundary around your bonfire. The black finish offers a stylish addition to your patio or yard. It helps contain sparks and provides a stable surface for placing items near the fire.

What is the main difference between the Basecamp 24 and the 42" Surround?

The Basecamp 24 is a complete, standalone smokeless fire pit for burning wood. It features a 24.6-inch diameter and a 360-degree airflow design. The 42" Surround is an accessory that adds safety and style to your fire area. It does not burn fuel itself but enhances the experience of your existing fire pit.

How big is the Solo Stove Basecamp 24-Inch Smokeless Fire Pit?

The Basecamp 24 measures 24.6 inches in width and length, with a height of 17.8 inches. This compact size makes it suitable for small outdoor gatherings. It fits well in backyards or patios where space is limited. The dimensions allow for easy portability while still providing ample room for cooking or warming.

What color options are available for these Solo Stove products?

The Solo Stove Basecamp 24-Inch Smokeless Fire Pit comes in a silver finish. The Solo Stove 42" Fire Pit Surround is available in black. These neutral colors blend well with various outdoor decor styles. The silver model highlights the smokeless design, while the black surround adds a modern touch to your fire setup.

Is the Basecamp 24 suitable for small groups?

Yes, the Basecamp 24 is ideal for small outdoor gatherings of five to seven people. Its 24.6-inch diameter provides enough space for comfort without taking up too much room. The smokeless design ensures cleaner air for everyone seated around it. It is a practical choice for intimate backyard evenings or small parties.

Does the 42" Surround add weight to my fire pit setup?

The Solo Stove 42" Fire Pit Surround weighs 46 pounds. This substantial weight ensures stability and safety around your fire. It helps keep the fire contained and provides a solid base for your setup. The size is listed as small, measuring 6 inches in width, 31 inches in length, and 23 inches in height.

See also

Prices and specifications on this page are read from the Amazon product listing and can change at any time. Scores are out of 10, based on listed specifications and buyer feedback. Nobody at this site handled or measured these products.