6 Best Alternatives to the Solo Stove 42″ Fire Pit Surround (2026)
As Amazon Associates, we earn from qualifying purchases. This means we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you if you click through and make a purchase.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
You might be looking for solo stove 42 fire pit surround alternatives because the original accessory has specific limitations. The Solo Stove 42" Fire Pit Surround is a 46-pound, powder-coated steel barrier that measures 31 inches in length and 23 inches in height. It provides a protective tabletop and a 360-degree safety shield for your existing fire pit. However, you may want a different size, a lighter weight, or a standalone unit that does not require an existing fire pit. Some buyers prefer a smokeless design or a propane option for easier control. Others might need a smaller footprint for a compact patio or a larger ring for a permanent installation. We selected these 6 alternatives because their specifications overlap with the original product’s core functions. Each option offers distinct dimensions, materials, or features that address different needs. You can compare the weight, size, and design to find the best fit for your outdoor space. This guide focuses on practical specs to help you decide.
How these options differ
Legacy Heating 35 inch Smokeless Fire Pit
The Legacy Heating 35 Inch Smokeless Fire Pit replaces your tabletop accessory with a complete, standalone unit. At 46.7 pounds, it is slightly heavier than the Solo Stove surround but offers a 35-inch diameter for seating six people. Unlike the surround, which protects an existing pit, this model provides its own smokeless design and portable structure. It lacks a tabletop surface, so you must bring your own serving area. Choose this if you need a dedicated fire source for larger groups rather than an add-on for a specific Solo Stove model.
ActiveTrail 30 Inch Smokeless Fire Pit
The ActiveTrail 30 Inch Smokeless Fire Pit is a compact alternative that weighs 46.3 pounds. It features a smokeless design and includes a lid, adding versatility for different uses. At 30 inches, it is smaller than the 31-inch long Solo Stove surround. While the surround acts as a protective barrier and table, this unit is a self-contained fire pit. It is best for small patios where space is limited. It does not fit over your existing Solo Stove 42, but it offers similar portability and safety features in a standalone package.
Ninja Fireside360 22-Inch Propane Fire Pit & Heater
The Ninja Fireside360 21.8 Inch Propane Fire Pit offers precise control via a dial, unlike the wood-burning Solo Stove surround. Weighing 40 pounds, it is lighter than the 46-pound surround. Its dimensions are 21.8 inches wide and 28.8 inches high. This propane unit provides smokeless warmth without the need for firewood or ash cleanup. It does not function as a tabletop or protective barrier for an open fire. Select this option if you prefer instant ignition and adjustable heat levels over the traditional bonfire experience provided by the Solo Stove accessory.
Solo Stove Bonfire Essential 19.5"
The Solo Stove Bonfire Essential 19.5 Inch is a standalone fire pit, not an accessory. It weighs 21.7 pounds, making it significantly lighter than the 46-pound surround. At 19.5 inches wide, it is much smaller and designed for portable camping or small gatherings. It features a smokeless design and includes a lid. Unlike the surround, which adds utility to a larger pit, this unit is a complete, self-contained system. It is ideal for users who want a lightweight, smokeless fire source without the bulk of a surround table.
Solo Stove Yukon 2.0 Big Yard Bundle
The Solo Stove Yukon 2.0 Big Yard Bundle is a larger, stainless steel fire pit with a stand. It weighs 40.4 pounds and measures 11.4 inches in width and length, with a height of 7.28 inches for the pit itself. This bundle is designed for big yards and regular outdoor use. It differs from the surround by being a primary fire source rather than an add-on. It offers easy cleanup and robust construction. Choose this if you need a heavy-duty, smokeless wood fire pit for larger spaces instead of a tabletop accessory for a smaller setup.
Iron Forge Tools 60-Inch Round Fire Pit Ring Insert
The Iron Forge Tools 60-Inch Round Fire Pit Ring Insert is a permanent solution for large backyard installations. It measures 60 inches in diameter and 10 inches in height. Unlike the portable 46-pound Solo Stove surround, this insert is designed for fixed locations. It features a smokeless design and round shape. It does not offer a tabletop surface or portability. This option is best for homeowners seeking durability and airflow in a permanent fire pit. It replaces the need for a surround by integrating directly into a larger, stationary fire structure.
| # | Product | Best for | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Solo Stove 42" Fire Pit Surround Best overall | Adding safety and a tabletop to a Solo Stove 42 | |
| 2 | Legacy Heating 35 inch Smokeless Fire Pit Best 6 people | groups of six seeking a portable wood fire pit | |
| 3 | ActiveTrail 30 Inch Smokeless Fire Pit Best budget | small patios and portable gatherings | |
| 4 | Ninja Fireside360 22-Inch Propane Fire Pit & Heater Best premium | Compact propane warmth with precise control | |
| 5 | Solo Stove Bonfire Essential 19.5" Best silver | portable smokeless camping and small gatherings | |
| 6 | Solo Stove Yukon 2.0 Big Yard Bundle Best stainless steel | Smokeless wood burning with a stand | |
| 7 | Iron Forge Tools 60-Inch Round Fire Pit Ring Insert Best round | permanent large backyard fire pit installations |
Solo Stove 42" Fire Pit Surround
Best for: Adding safety and a tabletop to a Solo Stove 42
- Outer Size
- 42"
- Primary Material
- Powder-coated steel
- Smoker Style
- Portable
- Color
- Black
- Dimensions
- 31 × 6 × 23 inches
- Weight
- 46 pounds
This tabletop accessory adds a protective barrier and serving surface to your Solo Stove 42 fire pit. It measures 31 inches long, 23 inches high, and weighs 46 pounds. The powder-coated steel and UV-resistant fabric withstand outdoor conditions. Adjustable feet keep it stable on grass or concrete. It creates a safe, elevated space for drinks and snacks around the fire.
- 360-degree protective barrier keeps hands and pets safe
- Perforated design minimizes heat absorption for tabletop use
- Powder-coated steel and UV-resistant fabric for durability
- Adjustable feet stabilize the unit on various surfaces
- Weighs 46 pounds, making it heavier than portable fire pits
- Limited to a single size option for the 42-inch model
- Height is fixed at 23 inches for this specific variant
- You want a safe barrier for children or pets near the fire
- You need a stable tabletop for snacks and drinks
- You have a Solo Stove 42 fire pit to attach it to
- You need a standalone fire pit without an existing stove
- You require a lightweight accessory for frequent travel
- You prefer a fire pit table with integrated burners
Verdict: Solo Stove 42" Fire Pit Surround is a sturdy, 46-pound accessory that adds safety and utility to your existing fire pit. It fits best if you want a dedicated, stable surface for food and drinks while keeping a protective barrier around the flames.
Legacy Heating 35 inch Smokeless Fire Pit
Best for: groups of six seeking a portable wood fire pit
- Fuel Type
- Wood, pellets
- Outer Size
- 35 inches
- Primary Material
- Stainless steel
- Smoker Style
- Portable
- Use
- Camping
- Color
- Black
This 35-inch wood-burning fire pit seats six people. Its double-wall design and top vents improve airflow for cleaner burns. The stainless steel interior and powder-coated exterior resist rust. You can move it using the side handles once it cools. A pull-out ash pan simplifies cleanup. The unit weighs 46.7 pounds and stands 21.5 inches tall.
- 35-inch diameter accommodates six people
- Double-wall design with top vents for better airflow
- Pull-out ash pan for easy cleaning
- Stainless steel interior with rust-resistant coating
- Portable design with side carry handles
- Weighs 46.7 pounds, which is heavier than lighter portable options
- Requires a two-hour cool-down period before using the handles
- Fixed height of 21.5 inches limits adjustability on uneven ground
- You need a fire pit for six people
- You want a smokeless design for cleaner burns
- You prefer easy ash removal with a pull-out pan
- You need a gas or propane fire pit
- You require a fire pit under 40 pounds
- You want a built-in height adjustment system
Verdict: Legacy Heating 35 Inch Smokeless Fire Pit fits groups of six who want a portable, wood-burning option with a clean burn design. It is a solid choice for backyard gatherings where easy ash removal matters.
ActiveTrail 30 Inch Smokeless Fire Pit
Best for: small patios and portable gatherings
- Outer Size
- 30 inches
- Primary Material
- 304 Stainless Steel
- Smoker Style
- Portable
- Features
- Lid, Fire Pit Table
- Use
- Camping
- Color
- Black
This ActiveTrail unit combines a 30-inch fire bowl with a removable ash pan and bamboo lid. The dual-level airflow system promotes secondary combustion for a cleaner burn. It transforms into a dining table when covered. The 304 stainless steel body resists heat and weather. At 46.3 pounds, it is portable enough for camping or patio use.
- 30-inch diameter provides ample space for gatherings
- Dual-level airflow system enhances smokeless burning
- Includes bamboo lid for table conversion
- Pull-out ash pan simplifies maintenance
- 30-inch size is smaller than the 35-inch and 60-inch competitors
- 46.3-pound weight is lighter than many heavy-duty stationary rings
- Single height option limits customization compared to adjustable models
- You need a fire pit that doubles as a dining table
- You prefer a portable unit for camping or beach trips
- You want a smokeless design with easy ash cleanup
- You require a large fire pit for big backyards
- You need a gas-powered heater with push start
- You prefer a fixed, heavy-duty stone or metal ring
Verdict: ActiveTrail 30 Inch Smokeless Fire Pit offers a compact, versatile solution for smaller spaces. It fits buyers who value portability and multi-use functionality over large capacity.
Ninja Fireside360 22-Inch Propane Fire Pit & Heater
Best for: Compact propane warmth with precise control
- Fuel Type
- Propane
- Heat Output
- 80,000 BTU
- Outer Size
- 21.8 inches
- Ignition Type
- Push Start
- Color
- Black
- Design
- Smokeless
The Ninja Fireside360 is a 21.8-inch propane fire pit that delivers 80,000 BTUs of heat. It features a smokeless design and three modes: ambient flame, heat only, or both. The unit weighs 40 pounds and measures 28.8 inches high. You get push-start ignition and weather-resistant construction. This model suits you if you want reliable warmth without wood management.
- 80,000 BTU output for head-to-toe warmth
- Three modes: flame, heat, or combined
- Smokeless propane operation avoids ash cleanup
- Push-start dial for instant ignition
- 21.8-inch width is smaller than the 30-inch and 35-inch alternatives
- 40-pound weight limits portability compared to lighter portable options
- Propane fuel required instead of wood
- You want precise heat control with 80,000 BTUs
- You prefer a smokeless propane system over wood
- You need a compact 21.8-inch footprint
- You require a larger 30-inch or bigger diameter
- You prefer burning wood for traditional ambiance
- You need a portable unit under 40 pounds
Verdict: Ninja Fireside360 21.8 Inch Propane Fire Pit delivers strong heat for small gatherings. It fits you if you value smokeless convenience and precise dial control over wood burning.
Solo Stove Bonfire Essential 19.5"
Best for: portable smokeless camping and small gatherings
- Fuel Type
- Wood
- Outer Size
- 19.5"
- Primary Material
- 304 stainless steel
- Smokeless Design
- Yes
- Smoker Style
- Portable
- Features
- Lid
The Solo Stove Bonfire Essential Bundle is a 19.5-inch smokeless fire pit weighing 21.7 pounds. It includes a stand and lid for protected, portable warmth. The 304 stainless steel body with ceramic coating ensures durability. This model seats four people comfortably. It suits you if you want a lightweight, easy-to-clean option for camping or small backyards.
- 19.5-inch diameter provides ample space for four people
- Weighs only 21.7 pounds for easy portability
- Removable ash pan simplifies post-fire cleanup
- 304 stainless steel construction with high-heat ceramic coating
- 19.5-inch width is smaller than the 35-inch and 60-inch alternatives
- 21.7-pound weight is lighter but offers less mass than larger stationary units
- Wood-fired fuel type limits heat control compared to gas models
- You need a portable fire pit for camping trips
- You want a smokeless design for small backyard gatherings
- You prefer lightweight equipment that is easy to clean
- You require a larger fire pit for big parties
- You prefer gas or pellet fuel for instant control
- You need a high-BTU heater for cold weather
Verdict: Solo Stove Bonfire Essential Bundle 19.5" fits campers and small-space users who value portability and smokeless burning. It is ideal for intimate gatherings where easy cleanup matters.
Solo Stove Yukon 2.0 Big Yard Bundle
Best for: Smokeless wood burning with a stand
- Fuel Type
- Wood
- Outer Size
- 27"
- Primary Material
- 304 stainless steel
- Smokeless Design
- Yes
- Smoker Style
- Portable
- Dimensions
- 11.4 × 11.4 × 7.28 inches
This 27-inch smokeless fire pit uses a double-wall airflow design to burn wood efficiently. It is built from 304 stainless steel with a high-heat ceramic coating for durability. The bundle includes a stand for stability and features a removable ash pan for easy cleanup. Weighing 40.4 pounds, it offers a portable solution for backyard gatherings or camping trips while minimizing smoke and odors.
- 27-inch diameter provides ample burning space
- Constructed from durable 304 stainless steel
- Includes a stand for stable placement
- Removable ash pan simplifies maintenance
- Double-wall design reduces smoke output
- Heavier at 40.4 pounds than the 35-inch portable option
- Smaller diameter than the 60-inch ring insert
- Requires wood fuel rather than gas or pellets
- You want a stainless steel build that resists wear
- You need a smokeless design for cleaner air
- You prefer a bundled setup with a stand
- You need a gas-powered unit with push start
- You require a larger 36-inch or 60-inch diameter
- You want a lightweight portable option under 30 pounds
Verdict: Solo Stove Yukon 2.0 Big Yard Bundle suits buyers seeking a durable, smokeless wood fire pit with a convenient stand. It fits those who value easy cleanup and a robust stainless steel construction for regular outdoor use.
Iron Forge Tools 60-Inch Round Fire Pit Ring Insert
Best for: permanent large backyard fire pit installations
- Fuel Type
- Wood
- Outer Size
- 60 inches
- Primary Material
- Steel
- Color
- Black
- Design
- Smokeless
- Shape
- Round
This 60-inch round fire pit ring insert is built from heavy-duty steel with a high-temperature black paint finish. It features a 42-inch inner ring to contain logs and a 60-inch outer diameter for ample fire space. The design supports smokeless burning through specific airflow gaps. It is intended for permanent installation in one location, making it a sturdy option for fixed backyard setups.
- 60-inch outer diameter provides generous space for large fires
- 42-inch inner ring keeps logs contained for efficient burning
- Thick-gauge steel construction with rust-resistant black paint finish
- Designed for secondary combustion to reduce smoke output
- Non-portable design limits use to a single permanent location
- 60-inch diameter requires a larger footprint than standard pits
- Intended for above-ground or in-ground installation only
- You need a permanent fire pit insert for a large backyard
- You want a steel ring with a smokeless design
- You prefer a round shape with a 60-inch outer diameter
- You need a portable fire pit for camping or travel
- You have limited space and need a smaller diameter
- You want a fire pit that can be moved frequently
Verdict: Iron Forge Tools 60 Inch Round Fire Pit Ring suits homeowners seeking a large, permanent steel insert for a fixed backyard location. It is ideal for those prioritizing durability and smokeless airflow over portability.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Solo Stove 42" Fire Pit Surround | Legacy Heating 35 inch Smokeless Fire Pit | ActiveTrail 30 Inch Smokeless Fire Pit | Ninja Fireside360 22-Inch Propane Fire Pit & Heater | Solo Stove Bonfire Essential 19.5" | Solo Stove Yukon 2.0 Big Yard Bundle | Iron Forge Tools 60-Inch Round Fire Pit Ring Insert |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fuel Type | – | Wood, pellets | – | Propane | Wood | Wood | Wood |
| Heat Output | – | – | – | 80,000 BTU | – | – | – |
| Outer Size | 42" | 35 inches | 30 inches | 21.8 inches | 19.5" | 27" | 60 inches |
| Primary Material | Powder-coated steel | Stainless steel | 304 Stainless Steel | – | 304 stainless steel | 304 stainless steel | Steel |
| Smokeless Design | – | – | – | – | Yes | Yes | – |
| Ignition Type | – | – | – | Push Start | – | – | – |
| Fuel | – | Wood-Fired | – | – | Wood-Fired | Wood-Fired | – |
| Smoker Style | Portable | Portable | Portable | – | Portable | Portable | – |
| Features | – | – | Lid, Fire Pit Table | – | Lid | – | – |
| Use | – | Camping | Camping | – | – | – | – |
| Color | Black | Black | Black | Black | Silver | Stainless Steel | Black |
| Design | – | Smokeless | Smokeless | Smokeless | Smokeless | Smokeless | Smokeless |
| Shape | – | – | – | – | – | – | Round |
| Seating | – | 6 People | – | – | 4 People | – | – |
| Dimensions | 31 × 6 × 23 inches | 35 × 35 × 21.5 inches | – | 21.8 × 21.8 × 28.8 inches | 19.5 × 19.5 × 17.5 inches | 11.4 × 11.4 × 7.28 inches | 60 × 60 × 10 inches |
| Weight | 46 pounds | 46.7 pounds | 46.3 pounds | 40 pounds | 21.7 pounds | 40.4 pounds | – |
| Size | Small (20×42) | 35 inch | 30 Inch | 21.8in x 21.8in x 28.8in | BONFIRE Essential Bundle | YUKON 2.0 Big Yard Bundle | 60" Diameter |
| Model | Firepit Surround | CYBERPIT-ONE-B | ZUXCTCw4w6A5Qi39728EJQaPc3W | OF101BK | BUNDLE-ESS-SSBON-2.0 | BYB-YUKON-27-2.0 | IFT-FIREPIT-60R |
Frequently asked questions
Can I use the Legacy Heating 35 inch Smokeless Fire Pit as a direct replacement for the Solo Stove 42 surround?
No, it is not a direct replacement. The Legacy Heating unit is a standalone fire pit, not an accessory. It measures 35 inches in width and length, providing a complete burning area. The Solo Stove surround is a 31-inch barrier designed to fit around an existing pit. You would need to purchase the Legacy unit as a separate appliance rather than an add-on.
Which alternative is best for small patios or camping trips?
The ActiveTrail 30 Inch Smokeless Fire Pit is the best choice for compact spaces. It weighs 46.3 pounds and features a portable design suitable for camping. Its 30-inch size is smaller than the Solo Stove surround. It also includes a lid, making it versatile for different uses. This model prioritizes portability and multi-use functionality over large capacity.
Is there a smokeless option that does not require wood?
Yes, the Ninja Fireside360 22-Inch Propane Fire Pit & Heater uses propane instead of wood. It is smokeless and offers precise dial control for heat adjustment. The unit weighs 40 pounds and measures 21.8 inches by 28.8 inches. It fits small gatherings and provides warmth without the need for wood fuel or ash cleanup.
What is the largest fire pit ring available for permanent installations?
The Iron Forge Tools 60-Inch Round Fire Pit Ring Insert is the largest option. It has a 60-inch diameter and is designed for permanent backyard installations. It weighs significantly more than portable units and features a smokeless design. This insert suits homeowners who prioritize durability and fixed placement over the portability of the Solo Stove surround.
How does the Solo Stove Bonfire Essential compare in size to the surround?
The Solo Stove Bonfire Essential Bundle is much smaller than the surround. It measures 19.5 inches in width and length, with a height of 17.5 inches. It weighs only 21.7 pounds, making it highly portable. The surround is 31 inches long and weighs 46 pounds. The Bonfire is better for intimate gatherings, while the surround is an accessory for a larger pit.
Which option offers the most seating capacity for groups?
The Legacy Heating 35 Inch Smokeless Fire Pit is designed for groups of six. Its 35-inch diameter provides ample space for seating. The Solo Stove surround is an accessory, not a seating unit. Other options like the Ninja or ActiveTrail are smaller. If you need a dedicated space for six people, the Legacy Heating model is the most suitable choice among these alternatives.
See also
Prices and specifications on this page are read from the Amazon product listing and can change at any time. Scores are out of 10, based on listed specifications and buyer feedback. Nobody at this site handled or measured these products.
