Oklahoma Joe’s vs Masterbuilt Pellet Grills: Which Brand Fits You?
As Amazon Associates, we earn from qualifying purchases. This means we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you if you click through and make a purchase.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
When you compare oklahoma joe s vs masterbuilt pellet grill options, you see two very different approaches to outdoor cooking. Both brands offer black units designed for serious smoking, but they diverge sharply in operation. Oklahoma Joe's provides a charcoal drum smoker that blends grilling and smoking. Masterbuilt offers a vertical electric smoker focused on consistent, hands-off smoking. You need to decide between manual fuel control and digital automation based on your specific cooking habits.
Fuel Type
Charcoal
Electric
Smoker Style
Charcoal Drum Smoker
Vertical
Cooking Area
284 sq in
970 sq in
Features
Offset Smoker, Rib Hanging Kit
Digital Controller, Side Wood Chip Loader
Use
Grilling, Smoker
Smoker
Choose the first if
- You want to switch between low-and-slow smoking and high-heat grilling.
- You prefer authentic charcoal flavor and manual airflow control.
- You need a compact unit that saves space on smaller patios.
Choose the second if
- You need maximum cooking space for large batches of meat.
- You want digital temperature control for consistent results.
- You prefer an electric unit that requires no charcoal management.
Verdict
Choose the Oklahoma Joe's Bronco if you value versatility and authentic charcoal smoke in a compact footprint. Select the Masterbuilt 40-inch if you prioritize large capacity and digital precision for long smoking sessions. Your choice depends on whether you want a grill-smoker combo or a dedicated high-capacity smoker.
Charcoal Drum vs Digital Electric
Fuel Type
Edge: Oklahoma Joe's Bronco 18 in. Charcoal Drum Smoker
Oklahoma Joe's Bronco runs on charcoal and wood. You load up to 8 pounds of fuel into the drum to support long smoking sessions. This manual fuel system requires you to manage the fire yourself. Masterbuilt uses electric power. This unit plugs into a standard outlet, removing the need for charcoal or wood chunks as the primary heat source. The electric approach simplifies the process, but you lose the traditional charcoal flavor profile. If you prefer authentic smoke flavor from burning wood, the charcoal option is the clear choice. For convenience and consistent heat without fuel management, electric wins.
Cooking Area
Edge: Masterbuilt 40-inch Digital Electric Smoker
The Oklahoma Joe's Bronco offers 284 square inches of cooking space. This compact area fits well on patios or in smaller outdoor areas. The Masterbuilt 40-inch model provides significantly more room. Its specifications list over 850 square inches of cooking area, with some descriptions noting up to 970 square inches. This large capacity allows you to cook multiple large cuts simultaneously without crowding. If you need to feed a large group or smoke several racks of ribs at once, the Masterbuilt provides the necessary space. The Bronco is better for smaller households or limited storage.
Smoker Style
Edge: Oklahoma Joe's Bronco 18 in. Charcoal Drum Smoker
Oklahoma Joe's designs the Bronco as a drum smoker that also functions as a grill. It features an offset smoke chamber design that allows for both low-and-slow smoking and high-heat grilling. You can switch between modes quickly. Masterbuilt offers a vertical electric smoker. This style is dedicated primarily to smoking. It uses chrome racks stacked vertically to maximize space. The vertical design is efficient for smoking but does not offer the grilling versatility of the drum style. If you want a single unit that can sear steaks and smoke brisket, the Oklahoma Joe's is more versatile.
Temperature Control
Edge: Masterbuilt 40-inch Digital Electric Smoker
The Oklahoma Joe's Bronco relies on a purpose-built airflow system for temperature management. You adjust dampers and vents to control the burn rate and maintain heat. This requires practice and attention to maintain consistent temperatures over long cooks. Masterbuilt features a digital controller. This electronic system automates the heat output, making it easier to set a target temperature and let the machine maintain it. The digital interface removes the guesswork from temperature regulation. For beginners or those who want set-and-forget convenience, the Masterbuilt digital controller is the superior option.
Portability
Edge: Tie
The Oklahoma Joe's Bronco weighs 137 pounds and measures 44.4 inches wide by 26.6 inches long. While compact for a smoker, it is still heavy and bulky. The Masterbuilt 40-inch model weighs significantly less, though exact weight is not listed, its dimensions are 25.6 inches wide by 19.9 inches long. The Masterbuilt is narrower and has a smaller footprint. However, the Bronco’s drum design is often cited as space-saving compared to traditional offset smokers. Neither unit is truly portable, but the Masterbuilt’s smaller width may fit tighter spaces better. The Bronco offers more stable mass for heat retention.
Choose Your Ideal Grill Brand
You want authentic charcoal smoke flavor
Our pick: Oklahoma Joe's Bronco 18 in. Charcoal Drum Smoker
The Oklahoma Joe's Bronco uses charcoal and wood for true smoky taste. You get 284 square inches of cooking space with a rib hanging kit. Its heavy steel construction retains heat well. The fuel door lets you add charcoal without stopping your cook. This manual system gives you direct control over temperature and smoke intensity for traditional barbecue results.
You need maximum cooking capacity
Our pick: Masterbuilt 40-inch Digital Electric Smoker
The Masterbuilt 40-inch Digital Electric Smoker offers 970 square inches of cooking area. This large vertical space handles big batches of meat easily. The digital controller simplifies temperature management. You get chrome smoking racks for even heat distribution. The side wood chip loader adds flavor without interrupting the process. This unit is ideal for feeding large groups or catering events.
You prefer simple electric operation
Our pick: Masterbuilt 40-inch Digital Electric Smoker
You can plug in the Masterbuilt and let the digital controller handle the work. There is no charcoal to manage or fire to tend. The electric vertical design maintains consistent heat with minimal effort. You just add wood chips to the side loader for smoke. This set-and-forget approach is perfect for busy schedules. You get reliable results without the manual labor of charcoal grilling.
You want versatile grilling and smoking
Our pick: Oklahoma Joe's Bronco 18 in. Charcoal Drum Smoker
The Oklahoma Joe's Bronco acts as both a smoker and a grill. You can switch between low-and-slow smoking and high-heat grilling quickly. The compact drum design saves space on your patio. You get precise airflow control to adjust temperatures. This versatility allows you to cook different types of food. You enjoy the authentic charcoal flavor while having the flexibility to grill burgers or steaks.
Oklahoma Joe's Bronco 18 in. Charcoal Drum Smoker
Best for: Compact charcoal smoking with fuel access
- Cooking Area
- 284 sq. in.
- Fuel
- Charcoal
- Features
- Offset Smoker
- Use
- Grilling, Smoker
- Color
- Black
- Size
- Large
This Oklahoma Joe's Bronco is a 18-inch heavy duty charcoal drum smoker and grill. It offers 284 square inches of cooking area and weighs 137 pounds. The unit measures 44.4 inches wide by 43.4 inches high. Its design supports long smoking sessions with up to 14 hours of heat retention. You can switch between low-and-slow smoking and high-heat grilling. The compact footprint saves space compared to traditional offset smokers.
- 284 square inches of cooking space
- Holds up to 8 lb of fuel for 14+ hours
- Fuel door allows adding charcoal without removing food
- Compact design takes up about half the space of a traditional offset smoker
- Heavier build at 137 pounds
- Smaller cooking area compared to larger electric vertical smokers
- You want a compact smoker that fits on a patio
- You need to add fuel without interrupting your cook
- You prefer the authentic performance of charcoal smoking
- You require digital temperature control
- You need a large capacity for feeding a crowd
- You want an electric smoker for easier operation
Verdict: Oklahoma Joe's Bronco 18 Charcoal Drum is a practical choice for cooks who value authentic charcoal flavor and space efficiency. It fits users who want to smoke for long periods without constant refueling but do not need the massive capacity of a large electric vertical unit.
Masterbuilt 40-inch Digital Electric Smoker
Best for: dedicated vertical smoking with digital control
- Cooking Area
- 970 sq. in.
- Fuel
- Electric
- Smoker Style
- Vertical
- Features
- Offset Smoker, Digital Controller
- Color
- Black
- Shape
- Square
This Masterbuilt vertical electric smoker offers 970 square inches of cooking space. It features a digital controller and a side wood chip loader for consistent smoke. The unit measures 25.6 inches wide and 41.3 inches tall. It suits those who want a dedicated smoking appliance with automated temperature management. The square shape and chrome racks provide ample room for large cuts of meat.
- 970 square inches of vertical cooking space
- Digital controller for precise temperature settings
- Side wood chip loader for easy fuel access
- Chrome smoking racks included for durability
- Electric fuel source limits portability
- 41.3-inch height requires significant vertical clearance
- Square footprint may not fit narrow spaces
- You need dedicated smoking capacity for large batches
- You prefer automated temperature control over manual adjustments
- You have a covered patio with power access
- You want to cook with charcoal or wood pellets
- You have limited vertical space for tall appliances
- You need a grill for direct high-heat searing
Verdict: Masterbuilt 40-inch Digital Electric Smoker provides reliable, hands-off smoking for large cuts. It fits buyers who prioritize capacity and digital control over fuel versatility.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Oklahoma Joe's Bronco 18 in. Charcoal Drum Smoker | Masterbuilt 40-inch Digital Electric Smoker |
|---|---|---|
| Cooking Area | 284 sq. in. | 970 sq. in. |
| Fuel | Charcoal | Electric |
| Smoker Style | – | Vertical |
| Features | Offset Smoker | Offset Smoker, Digital Controller |
| Use | Grilling, Smoker | Smoker |
| Color | Black | Black |
| Size | Large | 40-inch Digital |
| Shape | – | Square |
| Dimensions | 26.6 × 44.4 × 43.4 inches | 19.9 × 25.6 × 41.3 inches |
| Weight | 137 pounds | – |
| Model | 25203120 | MB20072918 |
Frequently asked questions
Is Oklahoma Joe's Bronco a pellet grill?
No, it is not. The Bronco 18 uses charcoal and wood as its fuel source. It operates as an offset smoker rather than an electric pellet unit. You load up to 8 pounds of fuel manually into the drum. This design provides authentic charcoal flavor without requiring electricity or pellet hoppers.
Does Masterbuilt make charcoal grills?
The listed Masterbuilt model is not a charcoal grill. It is a digital electric smoker that relies on electricity for heat generation. It features a vertical design with a digital controller for automated temperature management. This unit prioritizes hands-off operation over the manual fire management required by charcoal models.
Which brand offers more cooking space?
The Masterbuilt 40-inch Digital Electric Smoker offers significantly more capacity. It provides over 850 square inches of cooking area. In comparison, the Oklahoma Joe's Bronco provides 284 square inches. If you need to smoke large cuts or feed a crowd, the Masterbuilt vertical unit is the larger option.
Are these units suitable for beginners?
The Masterbuilt model is easier for beginners due to its digital controller. You set the temperature, and the electric system manages the heat automatically. The Oklahoma Joe's Bronco requires manual fire management. You must monitor the charcoal and wood load yourself. This makes the electric smoker more forgiving for those new to smoking.
What is the difference in fuel types?
Oklahoma Joe's uses solid fuel, specifically charcoal and wood. You manage the fire directly for authentic smoke flavor. Masterbuilt uses electricity to power its heating element. It does not use pellets or charcoal in the listed model. Your choice depends on whether you prefer manual fuel control or automated electric heat.
Do these grills require a power outlet?
Only the Masterbuilt unit requires electricity. It is a digital electric smoker that needs a standard power outlet to operate its controller and heating element. The Oklahoma Joe's Bronco is a charcoal drum smoker. It does not need electricity and can be used anywhere you can safely manage charcoal and wood.
Which is better for small spaces?
The Oklahoma Joe's Bronco is more compact. It measures 26.6 inches in length and 44.4 inches in width. The Masterbuilt unit is larger, with a height of 41.3 inches and a width of 25.6 inches. If you have limited patio space, the smaller charcoal drum fits more easily into tight areas.
See also
Prices and specifications on this page are read from the Amazon product listing and can change at any time. Scores are out of 10, based on listed specifications and buyer feedback. Nobody at this site handled or measured these products.
