Electactic 51” Outdoor Propane Fire Alternatives: 6 Similar Picks Compared
As Amazon Associates, we earn from qualifying purchases. This means we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you if you click through and make a purchase.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
You are looking at electactic 51 outdoor propane fire alternatives to find the right fit for your patio. The original Electactic 51" Propane Fire Pit Table offers a broad 50.8-inch width and 50,000 BTU heat output. Its large surface area supports dining and social gatherings, while the steel construction and smokeless propane burner provide steady, clean warmth. This makes it a strong choice for large outdoor spaces where heat coverage and table utility matter most.
You might want a different option if your space is smaller or if you need a specific shape. Some buyers prefer a rectangular footprint for deck safety, while others seek a compact round design for tight corners. Others may prioritize included tank storage or a faux stone finish. We selected these 6 alternatives because their specifications overlap with the Electactic model. Each product shares the 50,000 BTU propane fuel source, ensuring comparable heat performance. The list includes variations in width, height, and material to match your exact dimensional needs.
How these options differ
Werph 42-Inch Steel Propane Fire Pit Table
The Werph 42-inch model trades the Electactic’s 50.8-inch width for a 42-inch length and 20-inch width. It shares the 50,000 BTU heat output but adds a glass wind guard and a dedicated tank holder. The rectangular shape and 76-pound weight suggest a heavier, more stable build than the Electactic’s 26-inch depth. You gain dining versatility and wind protection, but lose the wider surface area. This pick suits buyers who prioritize a complete dining setup with integrated storage over maximum tabletop space.
TLGREEN 30-Inch Round Propane Fire Pit
The TLGREEN 30-inch round fire pit is significantly smaller, measuring 30 by 30 inches with a height of 13 inches. It matches the 50,000 BTU heat output but sacrifices surface area for a compact footprint. It includes a lid, storage cabinet, and rain cover, offering more protection features than the Electactic. The separate tank holder provides flexibility but requires more floor space. This option is ideal for small patios where the Electactic’s large dimensions would be overwhelming, providing dual functionality in a tighter space.
PIZZELLO 43" Propane Fire Pit Table
The PIZZELLO 43-inch rectangular table measures 43.1 inches long and 23.8 inches wide, differing from the Electactic’s 50.8-inch width. It also delivers 50,000 BTU of heat. This model includes a lid and glass wind guard, features the Electactic lacks. The 25.2-inch height is taller than the Electactic’s 20.1 inches, making it better for standard dining chairs. It is deck-safe certified, a safety feature not listed for the Electactic. Choose this if you need a taller, rectilinear design with added wind protection and deck compatibility.
SERWALL 33.5" Square HDPE Fire Pit Table
The SERWALL 33.5-inch square fire pit is much smaller, with a 33.5-inch width and length, compared to the Electactic’s 50.8-inch span. It shares the 50,000 BTU output but uses HDPE material instead of steel. The 24.4-inch height is taller than the Electactic’s 20.1 inches. It includes a lid and glass wind guard, offering more protection features. The compact square shape fits tight spaces better than the Electactic’s large rectangular footprint. Pick this for a stylish, compact option that provides wind protection and a taller dining height in a smaller package.
Jocoevol 42-Inch 50,000 BTU Propane Fire Table
The Jocoevol 42-inch rectangular table measures 42 inches long and 20 inches wide, differing from the Electactic’s 50.8-inch width. It provides the same 50,000 BTU heat output. This model includes a lid and glass wind guard, features the Electactic does not list. The 12.6-inch height is lower than the Electactic’s 20.1 inches, making it a lower-profile option. It includes a tank holder for convenience. Choose this if you prefer a lower, rectangular design with added wind protection and integrated tank storage over the Electactic’s wider surface.
PIZZELLO 43-Inch Faux Stone Fire Table
The second PIZZELLO 43-inch model measures 43 inches wide and 27.4 inches long, differing from the Electactic’s 50.8-inch width. It matches the 50,000 BTU heat output. This unit features a faux stone finish, a lid, rain cover, and glass wind guard, offering more aesthetic and protective features than the Electactic. The 24.5-inch height is taller than the Electactic’s 20.1 inches. It weighs 89.5 pounds, indicating a heavier build. Select this for a textured, decorative look with comprehensive weather protection and a taller profile for dining comfort.
| # | Product | Best for | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Electactic 51" Propane Fire Pit Table Best overall | large patio gatherings and wide surface needs | |
| 2 | Werph 42-Inch Steel Propane Fire Pit Table Best dining set | dining versatility and tank storage | |
| 3 | TLGREEN 30-Inch Round Propane Fire Pit Best budget | Small patios needing a dual-function table and fire pit | |
| 4 | PIZZELLO 43" Propane Fire Pit Table Best premium | Deck-safe rectangular dining and fire combination | |
| 5 | SERWALL 33.5" Square HDPE Fire Pit Table Best black | small patios needing compact black heat | |
| 6 | Jocoevol 42-Inch 50,000 BTU Propane Fire Table Also great | smaller rectangular patios needing a heater-table combo | |
| 7 | PIZZELLO 43-Inch Faux Stone Fire Table Also great | Rectangular fire pit with faux stone finish and dining lid |
Electactic 51" Propane Fire Pit Table
Best for: large patio gatherings and wide surface needs
- Fuel Type
- Propane
- Heat Output
- 50,000 BTU
- Outer Size
- 51"
- Primary Material
- Steel
- Features
- Fire Pit Table
- Shape
- Rectangular
This 51-inch propane fire pit table delivers 50,000 BTU of steady heat for chilly evenings. It features a brown wood-grain steel tabletop and a stainless steel burner. The unit includes blue glass stones and stands 20.1 inches high. You get a wide 50.8-inch surface for drinks or decor. It fits well on patios where you want a large, warm gathering spot.
- Generous 50.8-inch width provides ample surface area
- 50,000 BTU output ensures consistent warmth
- Stainless steel burner resists corrosion
- 4-leg base offers stable support
- 50,000 BTU output matches most competitors on the list
- 20.1-inch height is standard for this category
- 51-inch footprint requires more patio space than smaller models
- You need a large surface for serving food and drinks
- You want a brown wood-grain aesthetic for your patio
- You prioritize wide heat coverage for larger groups
- You have limited patio space and need a compact unit
- You prefer a square or rectangular shape over a round one
- You want a higher heat output than 50,000 BTU
Verdict: Electactic 51-Inch Propane Fire Pit suits those who need a wide, stable heat source for large gatherings. Its broad surface makes it ideal for social events where space and warmth are priorities.
Werph 42-Inch Steel Propane Fire Pit Table
Best for: dining versatility and tank storage
- Fuel Type
- Propane
- Heat Output
- 60,000 BTU
- Outer Size
- 42 inches
- Primary Material
- Powder-coated iron, steel
- Ignition Type
- Automatic ignition
- Safety Certification
- CSA
The Werph 42-inch rectangular propane fire pit table offers 50,000 BTUs of heat. It includes a tank holder for 20-pound tanks and a glass wind guard. The steel surface features a two-layer coating for weather resistance. You get automatic ignition and adjustable height feet for stability. This set transforms into a dining table with the lid, making it a versatile addition to your patio.
- 50,000 BTU heat output
- Includes propane tank holder
- Glass wind guard included
- Automatic ignition system
- Two-layer powder-coated steel
- 76-pound weight is heavier than lighter competitors
- 42-inch length is smaller than the 51-inch option on this list
- 50,000 BTU is lower than the 60,000 BTU variant in its own lineup
- You want a complete set with a tank holder
- You need a dining table that converts to a fire pit
- You prefer a rectangular shape for your patio
- You require the maximum 60,000 BTU heat output
- You need a larger 51-inch table surface
- You prefer a round fire pit shape
Verdict: Werph 42" Rectangular Propane Fire Pit is a solid choice for those who value the convenience of an included tank holder and dining versatility. It suits buyers who prioritize a rectangular design and weather-resistant steel construction over raw heat power.
TLGREEN 30-Inch Round Propane Fire Pit
Best for: Small patios needing a dual-function table and fire pit
- Fuel Type
- Propane
- Heat Output
- 50,000 BTU
- Outer Size
- 30 inches
- Features
- Lid, Storage Cabinet, Fire Pit Table, Rain Cover
- Shape
- Round
- Dimensions
- 30 × 30 × 13 inches
This TLGREEN propane fire pit table offers 50,000 BTU of heat in a 30-inch round design. It uses a two-piece system that separates the burner from the tank for easier transport and flexible placement. The unit weighs 75 pounds and features a light gray finish. It includes a solid metal cover that turns the fire pit into a patio table. This modular approach suits those who want a cleaner look and easy setup.
- 50,000 BTU heat output for robust warmth
- Two-piece modular design separates burner from tank
- 304 stainless steel burner for durability
- Solid metal cover converts to a patio table
- Adjustable freestanding tank holder for stable placement
- 30-inch diameter is smaller than the 42-inch and 51-inch options on this list
- 75-pound weight is heavier than many standard fire pit tables
- Round shape may not fit rectangular patio layouts as well as square or rectangular units
- You want a modular system that separates the tank for easier transport
- You need a dual-function piece that serves as a table when not in use
- You prefer a compact 30-inch footprint for smaller patios
- You need a large 42-inch or 51-inch surface area for groups
- You prefer a rectangular or square shape to match your existing furniture
- You want an all-in-one unit without a separate tank stand
Verdict: TLGREEN 30-Inch Round Propane Fire Pit fits buyers who prioritize a compact, modular design that doubles as a patio table. It is ideal for smaller spaces where the 30-inch diameter and separate tank holder offer practical flexibility.
PIZZELLO 43" Propane Fire Pit Table
Best for: Deck-safe rectangular dining and fire combination
- Fuel Type
- Propane
- Heat Output
- 50,000 BTU
- Outer Size
- 43.11 inches
- Primary Material
- Polyurethane
- Ignition Type
- Electronic
- Safety Certification
- CSA
This PIZZELLO fire pit table offers 50,000 BTU of heat output in a 43-inch rectangular design. The faux stone finish provides a durable, aesthetic look suitable for decks. It includes a removable lid to convert the unit into a functional dining or coffee table. The slide-out tank storage keeps the 20-lb propane cylinder hidden yet accessible. Electronic ignition and a thermocouple safety feature ensure straightforward and secure operation for your outdoor space.
- 50,000 BTU heat output for steady flames
- Removable lid converts to a dining table
- CSA certified for safe propane use
- 304 stainless steel burner for longevity
- Slide-out storage for 20-lb propane tank
- 43-inch width is narrower than the 51-inch option
- 8-pound weight suggests a lighter build than heavier stone models
- Rectangular shape limits seating compared to round tables
- You want a rectangular table that doubles as dining space
- You need CSA certification for deck safety
- You prefer hidden propane tank storage
- You require a larger 51-inch surface area
- You prefer a round table shape for corner seating
- You need a heavier, more robust stone construction
Verdict: PIZZELLO 43" Rectangular Propane Fire Pit fits users who value versatile surface space and deck-safe certification. It serves those needing a compact rectangular footprint with integrated dining utility.
SERWALL 33.5" Square HDPE Fire Pit Table
Best for: small patios needing compact black heat
- Fuel Type
- Propane
- Heat Output
- 50,000 BTU
- Outer Size
- 33.5 inches
- Primary Material
- HDPE
- Ignition Type
- Pulse
- Features
- Lid, Fire Pit Table, Glass Wind Guard
This SERWALL propane fire pit table offers 50,000 BTU of heat in a compact 33.5-inch square design. The black HDPE panels and stainless steel burner provide durable, weather-resistant construction. A pull-out shelf simplifies tank access, while the glass wind guard protects the flame. It suits patios needing focused warmth and a modern, low-profile aesthetic without the bulk of larger rectangular models.
- 50,000 BTU heat output for rapid warming
- Black HDPE material resists weather deformation
- Pull-out shelf allows easy propane tank changes
- Glass wind guard stabilizes the flame in breezes
- Square shape fits snugly in smaller spaces
- 33.5-inch width is smaller than the 42-51 inch options on this list
- Square footprint provides less surface area for dining than rectangular alternatives
- 24.4-inch height is lower than typical table heights, requiring lower seating
- You need a compact fire pit for a small patio or balcony
- You prefer a black finish to match modern outdoor decor
- You want a square shape that fits into corner spaces
- You require a large dining surface for group meals
- You prefer a rectangular shape for a more traditional look
- You need a taller table to match standard dining chairs
Verdict: SERWALL 33" Black Square Propane Fire Pit delivers efficient heat in a compact footprint, making it ideal for small patios where space is limited but style matters.
Jocoevol 42-Inch 50,000 BTU Propane Fire Table
Best for: smaller rectangular patios needing a heater-table combo
- Fuel Type
- Propane
- Heat Output
- 50,000 BTU
- Outer Size
- 42 inches
- Primary Material
- Steel
- Safety Certification
- CSA
- Features
- Lid, Fire Pit Table, Glass Wind Guard
The Jocoevol 42-inch propane fire pit table delivers 50,000 BTUs of heat for outdoor gatherings. Its rectangular design fits decks and patios efficiently. The unit includes a wind guard, glass rocks, and a tank holder for a complete setup. You get a weather-resistant steel build certified for safety. It serves as a dining or coffee table by day and a heat source at night.
- Delivers 50,000 BTUs of heating power
- Includes a glass wind guard and decorative rocks
- Comes with a matching propane tank holder
- CSA certified for safety standards
- Weather-resistant steel construction
- 42-inch width is smaller than the 50-51 inch options on this list
- Rectangular shape offers less perimeter seating than round designs
- Height of 12.6 inches is lower than standard table height
- You need a heating source that also functions as a dining table
- You want a complete set with a tank holder included
- You have a rectangular patio space that fits a 42-inch unit
- You prefer a round fire pit for better social seating
- You need a larger 50-inch or 51-inch heating area
- You require a standard dining table height over 12.6 inches
Verdict: Jocoevol 42in Rectangular Propane Fire Pit fits buyers who prioritize a complete package with a tank holder and need a rectangular footprint for smaller decks. It suits those who want a multi-functional table that doubles as a heater.
PIZZELLO 43-Inch Faux Stone Fire Table
Best for: Rectangular fire pit with faux stone finish and dining lid
- Fuel Type
- Propane
- Heat Output
- 50,000 BTU/HR
- Outer Size
- 43"
- Primary Material
- Polyurethane
- Ignition Type
- Battery-operated
- Safety Certification
- CSA
The PIZZELLO 43" fire pit table offers 50,000 BTU of heat from a double-tube stainless steel burner. Its rectangular shape and faux stone finish provide a distinct look compared to the round or square options on this list. The unit includes a removable lid for dining use, a glass wind guard, and a pull-out tank drawer. It weighs 89.5 pounds and measures 43 by 27.4 inches.
- 50,000 BTU heat output with adjustable flame control
- Rectangular shape with faux stone polyurethane construction
- Includes removable lid, glass wind guard, and rain cover
- Pull-out drawer for 20 lb propane tank storage
- Heavier at 89.5 pounds compared to lighter rattan alternatives
- Smaller surface area due to 27.4-inch depth versus wider tables
- Battery-operated ignition requires separate purchase of batteries
- You want a rectangular fire pit with a faux stone finish
- You need a removable lid to convert the unit into a dining table
- You prefer a pull-out drawer for easy propane tank access
- You prefer a round or square fire pit shape
- You want a lighter unit for frequent moving
- You need a battery-free ignition system
Verdict: PIZZELLO 43" Rectangular Propane Fire Pit suits you if you want a rectangular fire pit with a faux stone finish and a removable lid for dining. It fits patios where a wider footprint is acceptable and easy tank access is a priority.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Electactic 51" Propane Fire Pit Table | Werph 42-Inch Steel Propane Fire Pit Table | TLGREEN 30-Inch Round Propane Fire Pit | PIZZELLO 43" Propane Fire Pit Table | SERWALL 33.5" Square HDPE Fire Pit Table | Jocoevol 42-Inch 50,000 BTU Propane Fire Table | PIZZELLO 43-Inch Faux Stone Fire Table |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fuel Type | Propane | Propane | Propane | Propane | Propane | Propane | Propane |
| Heat Output | 50,000 BTU | 60,000 BTU | 50,000 BTU | 50,000 BTU | 50,000 BTU | 50,000 BTU | 50,000 BTU/HR |
| Outer Size | 51" | 42 inches | 30 inches | 43.11 inches | 33.5 inches | 42 inches | 43" |
| Primary Material | Steel | Powder-coated iron, steel | – | Polyurethane | HDPE | Steel | Polyurethane |
| Ignition Type | – | Automatic ignition | – | Electronic | Pulse | – | Battery-operated |
| Safety Certification | – | CSA | – | CSA | – | CSA | CSA |
| Fuel | Propane | Propane | Propane | Propane | Propane | Propane | Propane |
| Features | Fire Pit Table | Fire Pit Table, Glass Wind Guard | Lid, Storage Cabinet, Fire Pit Table, Rain Cover | Lid, Fire Pit Table, Glass Wind Guard | Lid, Fire Pit Table, Glass Wind Guard | Lid, Fire Pit Table, Glass Wind Guard | Lid, Fire Pit Table, Rain Cover, Glass Wind Guard |
| Color | Brown(51 Inch) | Gray | light gray | Brown | Black | Brown | Gray |
| Material | – | – | – | – | HDPE | – | – |
| Shape | Rectangular | Rectangular | Round | Rectangular | Square | Rectangular | Rectangular |
| Dimensions | 26 × 50.8 × 20.1 inches | 42 × 20 × 18 inches | 30 × 30 × 13 inches | 23.8 × 43.1 × 25.2 inches | 33.5 × 33.5 × 24.4 inches | 20 × 42 × 12.6 inches | 27.4 × 43 × 24.5 inches |
| Weight | – | 76 pounds | 75 pounds | 8 pounds | – | – | 89.5 pounds |
| Model | HL-22-50-B | GF4202K | ZYQGREY | – | SW-Square Firepit Table-Black-New | Fire Pit Table01 | X50006 |
| Size | – | 42" | – | 43.11 x 23.82 x 25.19 inches | 33.5"(W) x 33.5"(L) x 24.4"(H) | 42in | 43 in |
Frequently asked questions
Does the Electactic 51-inch fire pit have a glass wind guard?
The provided data does not list a glass wind guard for the Electactic 51-inch model. It focuses on its 50,000 BTU heat output and broad surface area. Other options in this comparison, such as the Werph and Pizzello models, explicitly include glass wind guards to protect the flame. You should check the specific feature list for the Electactic unit if wind protection is a priority.
What is the weight of the Electactic 51-inch propane fire table?
The specifications for the Electactic 51-inch model do not include a weight measurement. In contrast, the Werph 42-inch table weighs 76 pounds, and the TLGREEN 30-inch unit weighs 75 pounds. The Pizzello 43-inch model is listed at 89.5 pounds. You may need to contact the manufacturer for the exact weight of the Electactic unit before moving it.
How does the Electactic 51-inch compare to the Werph 42-inch in size?
The Electactic 51-inch model offers a width of 50.8 inches and a length of 26 inches. The Werph 42-inch table is longer at 42 inches but narrower at 20 inches. Both provide 50,000 BTU of heat. The Electactic shape is more square, while the Werph is distinctly rectangular. Choose based on whether you need more width or more length.
Is the Electactic 51-inch fire pit suitable for small patios?
The Electactic 51-inch model is designed for large patio gatherings due to its 50.8-inch width. It is not ideal for small spaces where compactness is key. For smaller patios, consider the TLGREEN 30-inch round model or the SERWALL 33.5-inch square table. These units have significantly smaller footprints while still delivering 50,000 BTU of heat output.
Does the Electactic 51-inch model include a lid for dining?
The data for the Electactic 51-inch model does not mention an included lid. However, many other options in this list, such as the TLGREEN, Pizzello, and Jocoevol models, feature lids that convert the fire pit into a dining table. If you need a surface for meals, you should verify if the Electactic unit includes this accessory or purchase it separately.
What shape is the Electactic 51-inch propane fire pit?
The Electactic 51-inch model is a rectangular table with dimensions of 50.8 inches in width and 26 inches in length. This shape provides a wide, stable surface for social events. Other options include the round TLGREEN 30-inch model, the square SERWALL 33.5-inch table, and several rectangular designs like the Werph and Pizzello models. The Electactic offers a broad rectangular footprint.
See also
Prices and specifications on this page are read from the Amazon product listing and can change at any time. Scores are out of 10, based on listed specifications and buyer feedback. Nobody at this site handled or measured these products.
