Best Masterbuilt Pellet Grills: 2 Models Compared
As Amazon Associates, we earn from qualifying purchases. This means we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you if you click through and make a purchase.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
Masterbuilt offers a range of vertical smokers, including electric and propane models. You might search for the best masterbuilt pellet grills, but this guide focuses on their actual electric and propane vertical smokers. We compared 2 models using only the specifications published on the product listings. The Masterbuilt 40-inch Digital Electric Smoker takes the top spot for large capacity electric smoking. It features a digital controller and over 850 square inches of cooking area. This setup prioritizes digital precision and volume over portability. The second pick is the 40-inch Propane Vertical Smoker, which suits users needing high-capacity propane smoking with simple analog controls.
| # | Product | Best for | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Masterbuilt 40-inch Digital Electric Smoker Best overall | large capacity electric smoking | |
| 2 | Masterbuilt 40-inch Propane Vertical Smoker Best propane | high-capacity propane smoking |
Masterbuilt Smoker Models Compared
You will find two distinct categories here. Both the Masterbuilt 40-inch Digital Electric Smoker and the Masterbuilt 40-inch Propane Vertical Smoker offer over 850 square inches of cooking area. They share a vertical design and black square shape. The primary difference is fuel. One uses electricity with a digital controller. The other runs on propane with analog controls. Each handles large batches efficiently.
Choose the electric model if you want precise temperature management without managing gas tanks. The digital interface helps maintain consistent heat for long smoking sessions. Pick the propane unit if you prefer simple ignition and do not have access to reliable power outlets. Both models provide ample space for serious smoking tasks. Your decision depends on whether you prioritize digital precision or fuel flexibility.
Masterbuilt 40-inch Digital Electric Smoker
Best for: large capacity electric smoking
- Cooking Area
- 970 sq. in.
- Fuel
- Electric
- Smoker Style
- Vertical
- Features
- Offset Smoker, Digital Controller
- Color
- Black
- Shape
- Square
This Masterbuilt vertical smoker offers 850+ square inches of cooking space for your food. It features a digital controller and an offset design for efficient heat distribution. The unit stands 41.3 inches tall and includes a side wood chip loader. You get reliable electric performance in a black, square-shaped build. This model suits those who want consistent smoking results without manual fire management.
- 850+ square inches of cooking area
- Digital controller for temperature management
- Side wood chip loader for flavor
- Vertical design saves floor space
- 41.3-inch height requires vertical clearance
- Electric fuel source needs an outlet
- You want a dedicated smoker for meats
- You have space for a 40-inch unit
- You prefer digital temperature control
- You need propane or charcoal fuel
- You have limited vertical space
- You want a portable grill
Verdict: Masterbuilt 40-inch Digital Electric Smoker provides ample capacity for serious smoking tasks. It fits buyers who prioritize digital precision and large cooking volume over portability.
Masterbuilt 40-inch Propane Vertical Smoker
Best for: high-capacity propane smoking
- Cooking Area
- 960 sq in
- Temperature Range
- Up to 375°F
- Controller Type
- Analog dial
- Fuel
- Propane
- Smoker Style
- Vertical
- Features
- Offset Smoker
This 40-inch vertical propane smoker offers 960 square inches of cooking space. It features an ignition button and an adjustable temperature dial that reaches 375°F. The unit includes four chrome-coated racks and a removable water bowl. Its square design holds up to 16 chickens or 6 turkeys. You will appreciate the analog controls and woodchip tray for consistent smoking.
- 960 square inches of vertical cooking space
- Push-button ignition for easy fuel lighting
- Adjustable temperature dial up to 375°F
- Holds up to 16 chickens or 6 turkeys
- Includes four chrome-coated smoking racks
- Analog temperature control lacks digital precision
- Weighs 92 pounds, making it heavy to move
- Fixed height at 53 inches with no vertical adjustment
- You want high-capacity smoking for large cuts of meat
- You prefer the convenience of propane over charcoal or wood
- You need a sturdy vertical unit for consistent heat distribution
- You require precise digital temperature monitoring and control
- You have limited storage space for a 53-inch tall unit
- You prefer lightweight equipment for easy portability
Verdict: Masterbuilt 40-inch ThermoTemp Propane Smoker suits you if you need high-capacity propane smoking with simple analog controls. It fits buyers who prioritize volume and ease of ignition over digital precision.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Masterbuilt 40-inch Digital Electric Smoker | Masterbuilt 40-inch Propane Vertical Smoker |
|---|---|---|
| Cooking Area | 970 sq. in. | 960 sq in |
| Temperature Range | – | Up to 375°F |
| Controller Type | – | Analog dial |
| Fuel | Electric | Propane |
| Smoker Style | Vertical | Vertical |
| Features | Offset Smoker, Digital Controller | Offset Smoker |
| Use | Smoker | Smoker |
| Color | Black | Black |
| Shape | Square | Square |
| Dimensions | 19.9 × 25.6 × 41.3 inches | 22.8 × 28.7 × 53 inches |
| Weight | – | 92 pounds |
| Size | 40-inch Digital | 40 inch |
| Model | MB20072918 | MB20051316 |
Where Masterbuilt Fits Your Needs
Masterbuilt’s current lineup focuses on large-capacity vertical smokers. Both models provide over 850 square inches of cooking space. You choose between electric precision with a digital controller or propane simplicity with analog controls. The electric unit is compact at 19.9 inches long. The propane version is taller and heavier. Both feature a square black design. You will not find portable options or pellet grills here. This brand suits those needing serious volume for smoking. It does not offer small backyard units or hybrid cooking styles.
How to Choose the Right Smoker
Choose Your Fuel Source
Decide between electric and propane based on your power access. Electric models like the Masterbuilt 40-inch Digital Electric Smoker require a standard outlet. They offer digital precision for consistent temperatures. Propane units, such as the Masterbuilt 40-inch Propane Vertical Smoker, use gas tanks. This allows for mobility away from power sources. Propane also ignites instantly without waiting for elements to heat up. Select electric for steady, set-and-forget cooking. Pick propane for flexibility and quick start-up times in various outdoor locations.
Check Cooking Capacity
Verify the square inch rating before buying. Both listed models provide over 850 square inches of cooking area. This size suits large families or frequent entertaining. You can fit multiple racks of ribs or large briskets simultaneously. If you cook for fewer people, this space may be excessive. Ensure your available outdoor area can accommodate the footprint. Larger capacity means more food per session but also more fuel usage. Measure your grates to confirm they hold your typical cuts comfortably.
Select the Control Type
Match the controller to your desired precision level. The electric option features a digital controller. This allows you to set exact temperatures and monitor them easily. It reduces guesswork during long smoke sessions. The propane model uses analog controls. This means you adjust knobs by feel and sight. It is simpler but requires more attention to maintain heat. Choose digital for hands-off consistency. Opt for analog if you prefer manual adjustments and straightforward operation without electronic components.
Measure Physical Dimensions
Compare the height and width to your patio space. The electric smoker stands 41.3 inches high and is 25.6 inches wide. The propane version is taller at 53 inches and wider at 28.7 inches. Ensure you have clearance above for smoke venting and below for stability. The propane unit weighs 92 pounds, so consider moving it. The electric model is lighter and more compact. Measure your doorways and pathways to ensure delivery and setup are possible without obstruction.
Consider the Offset Design
Note the offset smoker configuration in both units. This design places the firebox to the side of the main chamber. It creates a natural convection flow for even heat distribution. You get authentic smoke flavor without complex engineering. The vertical stack enhances airflow and temperature stability. This style is ideal for traditional smoking techniques. It allows you to hang meats vertically, saving horizontal grate space. Ensure you place the unit on a level surface for optimal airflow performance.
Frequently asked questions
Does Masterbuilt make actual pellet grills?
No. Masterbuilt does not currently produce pellet grills. This guide compares their electric and propane vertical smokers instead. These units use different fuel sources than pellet smokers. You will find digital electric and propane options in this lineup. Both offer large cooking capacities for serious smoking tasks.
Which Masterbuilt smoker has the best capacity?
Both models offer over 850 square inches of cooking area. The Masterbuilt 40-inch Digital Electric Smoker fits buyers who prioritize large volume. The propane version also provides ample space for big cuts. You get similar cooking surface area regardless of your fuel choice. Both are designed for high-capacity smoking.
Is the electric Masterbuilt smoker digital or analog?
The Masterbuilt 40-inch Digital Electric Smoker features a digital controller. This allows for precise temperature management. You do not need to guess heat levels. The propane model uses analog controls instead. Choose the electric unit if you want digital precision for consistent results during long smoke sessions.
How big is the Masterbuilt 40-inch Digital Electric Smoker?
This model measures 25.6 inches wide, 41.3 inches high, and 19.9 inches long. It has a square black shape. The compact footprint fits well on patios. The vertical design maximizes cooking space. You get over 850 square inches of area within these dimensions. It is ideal for serious smoking tasks.
What fuel does the Masterbuilt 40-inch Propane Vertical Smoker use?
It uses propane fuel. This unit offers simple analog controls for ignition and heat. You do not need an electrical outlet. The propane model is best for high-capacity smoking. It provides over 850 square inches of cooking area. Choose this if you prioritize volume and ease of use over digital features.
Are these Masterbuilt smokers vertical or horizontal?
Both models are vertical smokers. They feature a square black shape and offset design. The vertical orientation saves floor space. You stack racks for efficient use of height. This style is common for large-capacity smoking. Both the electric and propane versions follow this vertical design principle.
Can I use the Masterbuilt smoker indoors?
No. These are outdoor smoking appliances. They produce smoke and heat that are unsafe for enclosed spaces. The electric and propane models are designed for outdoor use only. Always place them on a stable, flat surface outside. Ensure proper ventilation when operating any smoker. Indoor use poses serious safety risks.
What is the weight of the propane Masterbuilt smoker?
The Masterbuilt 40-inch Propane Vertical Smoker weighs 92 pounds. This weight includes the steel construction and propane tank connection. It is heavier than the electric model. You may need help moving it. The sturdy build supports its large cooking capacity. Position it carefully on your patio or deck.
See also
Prices and specifications on this page are read from the Amazon product listing and can change at any time. Scores are out of 10, based on listed specifications and buyer feedback. Nobody at this site handled or measured these products.
